Economic Irreversibility: The Universal Guiding Principle of Infection Control
© The Physical Society of Japan
This article is on
Economic Irreversibility in Pandemic Control Processes: Rigorous Modeling of Delayed Countermeasures and Consequential Cost Increases
J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 90, 114007 (2021).
It is preferable to avoid lockdowns, as lockdowns at seriously spread phases are very expensive. It would be economically better to utilize less intense countermeasures as early as possible to avoid lockdowns in later phases.

Since the early 2020, governments across the globe have grappled with preventing the spread of COVID-19 and mitigating the economic impacts of this deadly virus. Several debates have raged over the methods to balance stringent infection control while maintaining a sense of economic normalcy.
In this study, theories of thermodynamics have been used to generate a new concept termed as "economic irreversibility." It contends that delaying infection control measures is additionally expensive in the long run.
Although, certain economists have utilized a cost-benefit analysis to argue for timely intervention, its universal applicability remains questionable. This is because previous studies have been performed using numerical simulations that include investigating specific situations with given parameters the results of which depend on the socio-economic conditions and on the characteristics of the infectious agents.
To further develop a universal guiding principle to control pandemics, the author’s experience in thermodynamics is utilized.
A cost-benefit analysis is an optimization problem similar to exploring more efficient thermal cycles in thermodynamics. The benefit and cost are the reduction in infections, and the economic damage caused by the countermeasure, respectively. The efficiency of the countermeasure processes are theoretically compared with the same period in which the initial and the final infection status (the number of infected persons) remain the same.
The application of economic irreversibility showed that the delay in infection control results in increased costs and contradicts the idea that infection control translates into economic damage. In terms of thermodynamics, it can be said that early countermeasures render the situation more reversible.
Furthermore, this study did not require adjusting for different infectious diseases or socio-economic conditions, making it applicable on a wider scale. It can be applied to the current COVID-19 pandemic or probable future ones, regardless of whether “herd immunity” exists or not. To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first analytical study of the economic efficiency during pandemic control.
The validity of the present study is subject to the assumptions of the methodology. In this study, two principal assumptions have been made:
1. |
The intervention cost depends on the effective reproduction number, and its cost function is concave as to the effective reproduction number. |
2. |
The epidemic is in the infection-spreading phase and thus the infected population increases and decreases while obeying exponential dynamics. |
It is assumed that countermeasures are utilized in order corresponding to their cost-effectiveness. Moreover, exponential dynamics is a common feature of pandemics. Thus, the results are not restricted to a specific model; however, they demonstrate the basic underlying characteristics of pandemic countermeasures.
(Written by T. Hondou)
Economic Irreversibility in Pandemic Control Processes: Rigorous Modeling of Delayed Countermeasures and Consequential Cost Increases
J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 90, 114007 (2021).
Share this topic
Fields
Related Articles
-
Microswimmer Hydrodynamics Through the Lens of Jeffery’s Orbits
Electromagnetism, optics, acoustics, heat transfer, and classical and fluid mechanics
Cross-disciplinary physics and related areas of science and technology
2023-5-18
This review article summarizes the latest progress on Jeffery’s orbits and how they relate to the motion of microswimmers of various shapes, including sperms, bacteria, and even microrobots.
-
Towards a New Phase in Materials Science with Hyperordered Structures
Structure and mechanical and thermal properties in condensed matter
Cross-disciplinary physics and related areas of science and technology
Dielectric, optical, and other properties in condensed matter
Electron states in condensed matter
Atomic and molecular physics
Mathematical methods, classical and quantum physics, relativity, gravitation, numerical simulation, computational modeling
2023-5-1
A Special Topics edition of the Journal of the Physical Society of Japan features articles discussing recent advancements in hyperordered structures in materials, their applications, and the techniques for observing them.
-
What Determines Non-Newtonian Flow Behavior in Glass-Forming Liquids?
Cross-disciplinary physics and related areas of science and technology
Structure and mechanical and thermal properties in condensed matter
2023-3-20
Even minute structural changes can lead to significant reductions in the flow resistances of glass-forming liquids. Here, possible scenarios and predictions for two different classes of glass-forming liquids are provided.
-
Angle-Resolved Photoelectron Spectroscopy Microscopy: A Tool to Accelerate Nanomaterials Research
Electronic structure and electrical properties of surfaces and nanostructures
Structure and mechanical and thermal properties in condensed matter
Cross-disciplinary physics and related areas of science and technology
2023-2-10
Researchers have published a practical guide on new uses of photoelectron microscopy combined with valence band dispersion analysis. They visualized several-micrometers-wide graphite facets and precisely characterized the band structure.
-
Net-Pattern of Muskmelon Rind Favors a Common Mathematical Law
Cross-disciplinary physics and related areas of science and technology
Statistical physics and thermodynamics
2023-1-12
The surface of muskmelon is covered with a fine mesh-like net-pattern. The geometric features of the fine mesh appear unique for each individual, but hide an unexpected mathematical rule.